Randy Johnson

FBHOF Score:  94.5

- 1st among starters

- 1st among pitchers

- 1st overall

Greg Maddux

FBHOF Score:  89.3

- 2nd among starters

- 2nd among pitchers

- 3rd overall

Roger Clemens

FBHOF Score:  63.3

-3rd among starters

- 3rd among pitchers

- 6th overall

Pedro Martinez

FBHOF Score:  63.3

- 4th among starters

- 4th among pitchers

- 7th overall

Curt Schilling

FBHOF Score:  72.6

- 5th among starters

- 5th among pitchers

- 15th overall

Kevin Brown

FBHOF Score:  63.3

- 6th among starters

- 6th among pitchers

- 37th overall

Johan Santana

FBHOF Score:  61.3

- 7th among starters

- 7th among pitchers

- 47th overall

John Smoltz

FBHOF Score:  58.7

- 8th among starters

- 8th among pitchers

- 54th overall

Steve Carlton

FBHOF Score:  58.5

- 9th among starters

- 9th among pitchers

- 55th overall

Dwight Gooden

FBHOF Score:  56.9

- 10th among starters

- 10th among pitchers

- 64th overall

Fernando Valenzuela

FBHOF Score:  56.6

- 11th among starters

- 11th among pitchers

- 67th overall

Bret Saberhagen

FBHOF Score:  55.9

- 12th among starters

- 12th among pitchers

- 74th overall

David Cone

FBHOF Score:  52.9

- 13th among starters

- 13th among pitchers

- 92nd overall